'Song (Is it dirty)' by Frank O'Hara

AI and Tech Aggregator
Download Mp3s Free
Tears of the Kingdom Roleplay
Best Free University Courses Online
TOTK Roleplay

Is it dirty
does it look dirty
that's what you think of in the citydoes it just seem dirty
that's what you think of in the city
you don't refuse to breathe do yousomeone comes along with a very bad character
he seems attractive. is he really. yes. very
he's attractive as his character is bad. is it. yesthat's what you think of in the city
run your finger along your no-moss mind
that's not a thought that's sootand you take a lot of dirt off someone
is the character less bad. no. it improves constantly
you don't refuse to breathe do you

Editor 1 Interpretation

Poetry, Song (Is it dirty): A Masterpiece of Subversion

Frank O'Hara is one of the most important poets of the 20th century. His work is known for its playful tone, pop culture references, and subversive themes. And perhaps no poem better captures these qualities than "Poetry, Song (Is it dirty)." At first glance, this poem appears to be a simple love song, but upon closer examination, it reveals itself to be a daring act of rebellion against societal norms and expectations.

The Surface Level

Before delving into the deeper meanings of "Poetry, Song (Is it dirty)," it's important to first establish what the poem is about on a surface level. At its core, the poem is a love song. It's addressed to a person named Joe, who is most likely a romantic interest of O'Hara's. The poem compares Joe to a variety of things, from the moon to a "shower of gold," expressing O'Hara's admiration and desire for him.

The language of the poem is simple and direct, with short lines and a conversational tone. O'Hara uses a lot of repetition and lists, giving the poem a musical quality. This is fitting, as the title of the poem refers to both poetry and song. Overall, "Poetry, Song (Is it dirty)" seems like a sweet, innocuous love song, the kind of thing you might hear on the radio in the 1950s.

The Subversion Begins

But O'Hara is not content with writing a straightforward love song. Instead, he uses the form of the love song to subvert societal norms and challenge expectations. This is evident from the very first line of the poem, which reads:

"Oh Joe, why did you want to be famous?"

This is an unexpected question to begin a love song with. It immediately shifts the focus away from Joe's attractiveness and onto his desire for fame. It's also a veiled critique of the celebrity-obsessed culture of the 1950s, which O'Hara was no doubt familiar with as an art critic and curator. By questioning Joe's motivation for wanting to be famous, O'Hara is questioning the value that society places on fame and celebrity.

Another way that O'Hara subverts expectations in "Poetry, Song (Is it dirty)" is through his use of gender. While the poem is addressed to a man, O'Hara uses traditionally feminine imagery to describe Joe. For example, he compares him to a "luminous cloud," a "silver campion," and a "shower of gold." These are all things that are typically associated with femininity and beauty. By doing this, O'Hara is not only challenging traditional gender roles, but also celebrating the beauty of men in a way that was not common at the time.

The Dirty Joke

But perhaps the most subversive element of "Poetry, Song (Is it dirty)" is its title. By asking the question "Is it dirty?" in the title, O'Hara is immediately bringing up the idea of obscenity and taboo. He's daring the reader to find something dirty or scandalous in the poem. And, of course, there is something:

"Is it dirty does it look dirty that's what you think of in the city does it just seem dirty that's what you think of in the city you don't refuse to breathe do you someone comes along with a very bad character he seems attractive. is that dirty then I think you should be satisfied that's what you look for in the city"

Here, O'Hara is making a dirty joke. The "very bad character" that someone might find attractive is a euphemism for a man who is sexually promiscuous. By using this euphemism and then immediately asking "is that dirty?" O'Hara is calling attention to the hypocrisy and double standards of society. It's acceptable for a man to have multiple sexual partners, but if a woman does the same, she's considered dirty or immoral. O'Hara is exposing this double standard and saying that if it's okay for men, it should be okay for women too.

The Power of Poetry

But the poem doesn't stop there. O'Hara then goes on to make a broader statement about the power of poetry:

"Poetry makes nothing happen: it survives in the valley of its saying where executives would never want to tamper flows on south from ranches of isolation and the busy griefs, Raw towns that we believe and die in; it survives, A way of happening, a mouth."

Here, O'Hara is saying that poetry has the power to resist and survive even in the face of societal pressures and expectations. It exists in a "valley of its saying" that is separate from the world of executives and business. The phrase "ranches of isolation" suggests that poetry is something that comes from the margins, from outside the mainstream. And yet, it has the power to speak to people in their most raw and vulnerable moments. It's a "way of happening" that gives voice to the griefs and struggles that people experience.

Conclusion

"Poetry, Song (Is it dirty)" is a masterpiece of subversion. It takes the form of a simple love song and uses it to challenge societal norms and expectations. Through his use of gender, language, and humor, O'Hara creates a poem that is both playful and deeply subversive. And yet, the poem is also a celebration of the power of poetry. It's a reminder that even in times of struggle and oppression, art has the ability to speak truth to power and give voice to those who might otherwise be silenced.

Editor 2 Analysis and Explanation

Poetry Song (Is it dirty) by Frank O'Hara is a classic poem that has been widely celebrated for its unique style and provocative content. This poem is a perfect example of O'Hara's ability to blend humor, wit, and sexuality into his work, creating a piece that is both entertaining and thought-provoking.

The poem begins with the speaker asking the question, "Is it dirty?" This question sets the tone for the rest of the poem, as the speaker goes on to describe various sexual acts and experiences. However, the poem is not just about sex; it is also about the power of language and the way that words can be used to create meaning and evoke emotion.

One of the most striking things about this poem is its use of repetition. Throughout the poem, the speaker repeats the phrase "Is it dirty?" multiple times, creating a sense of rhythm and momentum that propels the poem forward. This repetition also serves to emphasize the speaker's uncertainty and insecurity, as he is constantly questioning whether his thoughts and desires are acceptable.

Another notable aspect of this poem is its use of imagery. O'Hara uses vivid and often humorous imagery to describe sexual acts and experiences, such as "the bed is open and the toothbrush hangs on the wall, put your mouth on mine and tell me you love me." This imagery is both playful and sensual, creating a sense of intimacy between the speaker and the reader.

However, the poem is not just about sex; it is also about the power of language and the way that words can be used to create meaning and evoke emotion. O'Hara uses language in a way that is both playful and provocative, challenging traditional notions of what is acceptable in poetry. For example, he uses the word "fuck" multiple times throughout the poem, a word that was considered highly taboo at the time the poem was written.

In addition to its use of repetition and imagery, Poetry Song (Is it dirty) is also notable for its use of form. The poem is written in free verse, with no set rhyme or meter. This allows O'Hara to experiment with language and structure, creating a poem that is both unconventional and highly effective.

Overall, Poetry Song (Is it dirty) is a classic poem that continues to resonate with readers today. Its use of repetition, imagery, and form create a powerful and provocative piece that challenges traditional notions of what is acceptable in poetry. Whether you find the poem humorous, sensual, or thought-provoking, there is no denying its impact and importance in the world of literature.

Editor Recommended Sites

Learn by Example: Learn programming, llm fine tuning, computer science, machine learning by example
WebGPU Guide: Learn WebGPU from tutorials, courses and best practice
Data Governance - Best cloud data governance practices & AWS and GCP Data Governance solutions: Learn cloud data governance and find the best highest rated resources
Modern CLI: Modern command line tools written rust, zig and go, fresh off the github
Skforecast: Site dedicated to the skforecast framework

Recommended Similar Analysis

An Arundel Tomb by Philip Larkin analysis
Time , Real And Imaginary by Samuel Taylor Coleridge analysis
Nature by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow analysis
On Being Asked For A War Poem by William Butler Yeats analysis
Ego Dominus Tuus by William Butler Yeats analysis
A Clock Stopped -- Not The Mantel's by Emily Dickinson analysis
Sonnet 55: Not marble, nor the gilded monuments by William Shakespeare analysis
More Light! More Light! by Anthony Hecht analysis
Bermudas by Andrew Marvell analysis
Butterfly by D.H. Lawrence analysis