[ Join Free! ]
(No Spam mail)

  • RolePlay
  • Join Us
  • Writings
  • Shoutbox
  • Community
  • Digg Mashup
  • Mp3 Search
  • Online Education
  • My Youtube
  • Ear Training
  • Funny Pics
  • nav

  • Role Play
  • Piano Music
  • Free Videos
  • Web 2.0
  • nav

    << | >>

    dots Submission Name: Editing~ Discussiondots

    Author: jaycee
    ASL Info:    44/F/ Texas
    Elite Ratio:    5.27 - 2626/1259/187
    Words: 111
    Class/Type: Misc/Serious
    Total Views: 596
    Average Vote:    No vote yet.
    Bytes: 545

       Discussion for everyone to join in. I'd like to hear your opinion on this. Since we don't have a forum anymore, this is the place.

    Make the font bigger!! Double Spacing Back to recent posts.

    dotsEditing~ Discussiondots

    Okay, I have been testing out some other forums. Elite is my primary forum, but I still like to get out there to compare critique and advise.

    On one forum I was told that you should not revise a poem until at least six months have gone by. I was told you cannot make a good edit if you edit quickly. I'm having a hard time swallowing that one. If you were trying to publish a book, trust me, your editor would not allow you to wait 6 months for an edit of 30 lines.

    So how long do you wait to edit and why?

    Submitted on 2015-01-30 17:29:08     Terms of Service / Copyright Rules
    Submissions: [ Previous ] [ Next ]

    Rate This Submission

    1: >_<
    2: I dunno...
    3: meh!
    4: Pretty cool
    5: Wow!

    ||| Comments |||
      To be honest, it is silly to put time frames on editing and rewriting. Perhaps they mean to say, you should get back to it with a clear head and no attachment to it so that you feel that you can make it better and not cry over every line that you change or delete. But who can say when that is? You can do it the same day. You can do it in a year. That is for you to decide.

    I rarely rewrite my poems. I either tweak them to make them more sound (and of course correct grammar), but rarely rewrite. I feel that if I rewrite too much, my voice will be completely lost...and so will the meaning. I'd rather then discard it than have a poem written that is meaningless to me.
    | Posted on 2015-02-02 00:00:00 | by wordsofmind | [ Reply to This ]
      I've occasionally edited an original work until it morphed into something entirely different, but that was to satisfy myself before I went public with it. After it was posted, the dialogue about meaning and change solidified but I rarely did much with it right away unless I was dissatisfied with the original and felt compelled to either tweak it or gut it. Follow your instincts and listen to those you trust to help with the preliminary post and then pay attention to how the general public receives the post.

    Just my thoughts.
    | Posted on 2015-02-01 00:00:00 | by rws | [ Reply to This ]
      I write. I revise. Then I revise again, and again, and again, many times before taking it public. With meaningful criticism, I may revise again, immediately. The key word in that sentence being "meaningful." I will then wait. How long? Well until I have decided to change something, either through my own discovery or, perhaps, through criticism from others.
    I believe it is up to the artistic inclinations of the author and not a time clock as to when to edit a piece. I find myself editing pieces of five or ten years of life, and I edit yesterdays works as well.
    I frequently quote W. H Auden, who said, when asked to what he attributed his poetic success, replied, "Revise, revise, revise."
    It surely remains the writers choice.
    | Posted on 2015-01-30 00:00:00 | by phil askew | [ Reply to This ]
      I know it seems weird to comment on your own post but I'm going to leave my philosophy.

    I rarely edit directly after I post, unless it is misspellings or punctuation. I do not have a set time, but I ususally post for critique and then wait until I'm not emotionally attached to what I wrote: Sometimes that is weeks, and sometimes it is days. It really depends on why I wrote the piece. Things that I write as a challenge, usually do not have a lot of sentimental value and I can edit them within days and do a good job. Other pieces I wait. And some, I can look back on after years and see things to tweak, but then I have to decide if I change it or let it be part of my portfolio.

    Even famous writers morph over time with style and word choice getting more sophisticated. I think that is part of the growth process.
    What are your thoughts?
    | Posted on 2015-01-30 00:00:00 | by jaycee | [ Reply to This ]

    Think Feedback more than Compliments :: [ Guidelines ]

    1. Be honest.
    2. Try not to give only compliments.
    3. How did it make you feel?
    4. Why did it make you feel that way?
    5. Which parts?
    6. What distracted from the piece?
    7. What was unclear?
    8. What does it remind you of?
    9. How could it be improved?
    10. What would you have done differently?
    11. What was your interpretation of it?
    12. Does it feel original?


    Be kind, take a few minutes to review the hard work of others <3
    It means a lot to them, as it does to you.

    Primitive Lapse written by Crestfallenman
    winners circle written by ShyOne
    My Four Seasons written by faideddarkness
    Supernatural Cowboy Sleuth (4) written by endlessgame23
    The Old Mill written by Wolfwatching
    to Be like written by KeeperOfLight
    Carry written by saartha
    a mood to be free written by Daniel Barlow
    i've missed written by mysalvation
    4th Season of Vivaldi written by HisNameIsNoMore
    You read free written by poetotoe
    phantom limbs written by expiring_touch
    a safe place written by Daniel Barlow
    Blood Stains Are The Worst written by ForgottenGraves
    Supernatural Cowboy Sleuth (final) written by endlessgame23
    Your Lover written by Cordell
    Records I written by Raphael
    The Unicorn written by BlazeFlamme
    Supernatural Cowboy Sleuth (2) written by endlessgame23
    the living moment written by ShyOne
    an unashamed poverty written by Daniel Barlow
    Comme un lion en avril written by Outlaw
    Deep Into A World Of Despair written by DeathTone
    Physician, Heal Thyself written by WriteSomething
    Silent Screams In Silent Dreams written by poetotoe
    Yes written by poetotoe
    Shut Up written by annie0888
    the testing of hypotheses written by Daniel Barlow
    prison written by ShyOne
    Supernatural Cowboy Sleuth (3) written by endlessgame23




    User Name:


    [ Quick Signup ]
    [ Lost Password ]

    January 10 07
    131,497 Poems

    I have 14,000+ Subscribers on Youtube. See my Video Tutorials

    [ Angst Poetry ]
    [ Cutters ]
    [ Famous Poetry ]
    [ Poetry Scams ]

    [ Smaller ] [ Bigger ]